6 Best Places to Eat Italian Food in Niagara Falls


Italian cuisine has been the heartbeat of the Niagara Falls area for many generations. As Italian families arrived on Ellis Island, they began looking for work and living arrangements across the U.S. and Canada, with many people landing here in Niagara Falls, New York, to settle into jobs in the hydropower plants around the area.   

Families put down their roots figuratively and literally here. The climate and growing conditions of our area were ideal to grow and obtain the fruits and vegetables similar to what they knew before crossing the Atlantic Ocean. In fact, agriculture is the largest industry here ahead of tourism. Our Italian cuisine truly represents the perfect intersection of both agriculture and tourism — and we can’t wait to share it with you. Here are six of our favorite places to start. Mangia! Mangia!

Bella Vista Ristorante 

This restaurant has an absolutely breathtaking view of the slow moving upper Niagara River. It’s also one of the best spots to enjoy Italian food in Niagara Falls. Bella Vista’s menu changes seasonally but always features beautiful in-season vegetables paired with hand-rolled fresh pasta. This restaurant is tucked into the beautiful Niagara Riverside Resort.

Michael’s Restaurant

Nestled in the “Little Italy” area of Niagara Falls, this is the place to go for homestyle pastas and hearty dishes. Don’t miss the beans and greens soup. This super garlicky and leafy green soup that has a soul of its own.

The Como Restaurant and Lounge 

This restaurant is the most synonymous name with Italian Food in Niagara Falls. For nearly a century, the Antonacci and Colucci families have been serving traditional dishes from the south of Italy like veal francesca, chicken cacciatore, and veal parmigiana. Food from the Como is the closest thing you can get next to eating food made by an Italian nana.

Fortuna’s Restaurant and Banquets 

Two words: chicken parm. The Italian-American classic is absolutely the star of the menu at this swanky 1970s-style Italian restaurant. You’ll find Fortuna’s around the corner from the Niagara Falls City Market in “Little Italy.” The Fortuna family have been serving up their delicious southern Italian specialties for more than four generations. These time-tested, traditional-style recipes have been passed down for more than 70 years, giving locals today the amazing food that their grandparents enjoyed decades ago.

Casa Antica 

This family-run Italian restaurant on Center Street in historic Lewiston is approximately 7 miles north of Niagara Falls has an awesome al fresco dining experience. The authentic homemade dishes originate from both southern and northern Italy. Chef Calogero Soldano prepares their fresh Italian cuisine daily, including their mouth watering arancini (rice balls), antipasti, as well as their ever-changing rotation of fresh pasta dishes.

Carmelo’s Coat of Arms

Also located in the quaint village of Lewiston, NY, stands an intimate casual restaurant specializing in regional Italian cuisine. The heartbeat of the menu is its local seasonal products. This second-generation landmark is a must visit in our region. Lumache alla vodka pancetta pangrattato may be a mouthful for pronunciation, but start practicing now: you’ll be raving about it about it for days after ordering it.